There’s quite a lot of areas of training and behaviour we get involved in that we believe we know are “good” for dogs. Like scentwork (in its various forms) for example. The oft cited figure that a dog needs “10 hours” of sleep is another.
And we could be right – without any science to say so. Experience and expertise are important and not to be ignored. Take this video of a dog searching – tracking in her own “wild tracking” style – you don’t need academic evidence to tell you this dog is happy doing it! (Assuming we “know” – are correct – that what we are seeing signs of happiness of course!) and if we care about our dogs, we will look to do things with, or for, them to help them be happy, won’t we?
But…when someone says “it’s good for dogs” it’s not always that obvious is it? It’s also not obvious what a “happy” dog is. Is being content good enough? Is happiness as a contrast to UNhappiness really the happiness we would want for our dogs? That relief a dog might show because he has managed to avoid something unpleasant or something bad has stopped happening – is that “happy”? Is it “good” for our dogs to experience that?
So when someone says to me firmly “a dog needs 10 hours sleep a day” to be happy I want to know – 1) how do they KNOW that? What is their evidence? 2) is that all through the day, or just nighttime? 3) what sort of sleep? Is dozing for 10 hours out of boredom, with lack of anything else to do, quality sleep?

We probably will never know all the answers to questions we ask – in the meantime practical, practised and experienced trainers sharing their knowledge and skills through courses and training are invaluable and essential. Their experience of living and working with dogs first hand is invaluable and important. Of course, not everything they (we!) do will be benefitting the dogs in the way we fondly hope – we change our opinions and techniques as we evolve, learn and make mistakes. But forming theories – asking the questions – finding evidence to inform us is also important and is just another part of how we can learn to help our dogs to be happy and learn what is “good” for them. The two aren’t always as joined up as they could be perhaps – but that is a subject for another day.